Gabe Logan wrote:
It certainly is better than GTA4! I don't like the GTA series, so...
You can't say that before you play both games. GTA4 is totally different, and has a main character you actually care about his background story. You can be a 'good' guy, kinda like Snake. You have to make choices that affect the story, such as killing or sparing people. GTA4 might be worth a shot, even for you.
There are also common complaints about MGS4, such as serious lack of gameplay. The previous games had that but in the last few acts you barely play at all. I'm serious you have 30 minutes or cutscenes and 5-10 minutes of gameplay, then to have a scene of an hour. There not many bosses and they are seriously poorly done, except a few. As usual they are as unrealistic like every most bosses in the MGS universe.
It has a slow start but it will pick up very soon, but Hideo Kojima really has serious problems with explaining stuff. He made things just not needed long while some things can be explained in 1 sentence he does it in 10 minutes! You can also only call 2 people on the Codec.. And in the last few acts there are no human soldiers, but just black creatures.
That aside, the story is excellent. The voice acting is top notch, the scenes are very cool and the graphics are awesome. There is little gameplay, but the gameplay you have is really good, CQC didn't improve much compared to MGS3, you have camo but healing wounds like in MGS3 has been removed and the traditional Rations are used to heal.
For story I'd play MGS4, for gameplay I'd play Syphon Filter or GTA4.